Redrawing the map of Great Britain based on human interaction


A group of researchers at MIT, Cornell University and University College London have used one of the world’s largest databases of telecommunications records to redraw the map of Great Britain. The research, which will be published in the journal PLoS ONE on Dec. 8, is based on the analysis of 12 billion anonymized records representing more than 95 percent of Great Britain’s residential and business landlines.

“Since the pioneering work of Christaller and Lösch in the early 20th century, a long-standing question in economic geography has been how to define regions in space,” explains Carlo Ratti, director of the MIT Senseable City Lab and one of the paper\’s authors. “Our paper proposes a novel, fine-grained approach to regional delineation, based on analyzing networks of billions of individual human transactions.”

Given a geographical area and some measure of the strength of links between its inhabitants, the paper describes mathematically how to partition the area into smaller, non-overlapping regions while minimizing the disruption to each person’s links. For the most part, the results of the partitioning correspond remarkably well with existing administrative regions, but they still unveil some unexpected spatial structures.

“We have discovered a new region just west of London which corroborates an earlier hypothesis of a ‘western crescent’ centered on high-tech activities,” explains the Francesco Calabrese, one of the paper’s authors. Wales, and to a lesser extent Yorkshire, also seem to have been incorporated into regions dominated by the major cities of the West and East Midlands regions, respectively.

“The difference between Scotland and Wales is striking,” adds Ratti. “Based on our landline data, Scotland is very separated from the rest of Great Britain: just 23.3% of all call time placed or received there goes to or comes from another part of the country. Conversely, Wales, in spite of its unique cultural and linguistic heritage, is well integrated with its English neighbors to the East.”

It’s unlikely, of course, that Wales and England are going to merge anytime soon, so the discovery that several Welsh cities seem to depend heavily on the exchange of information with nearby English cities, and vice versa, probably won’t have major political consequences. But, Ratti says, the value of the new work is that it shows that analyzing information flow could be a useful tool in the drawing of political boundaries. And, he says, it will only become more useful as data from other networks — the Internet, Internet telephone networks, instant-messaging networks — become available for analysis.

The paper’s approach belong to an emerging field that has been recently termed “computational social sciences” — i.e., the ability to address social-science research questions using huge datasets that have emerged over the past decades as a result of digitalization. “We are particularly interested in how rich data at the individual level can promote a better understanding of our society, which, in the future, could lead to more democratic, bottom-up structures of governance,” adds Calabrese.

“Very little in network theory has been done, believe it or not, on networks in geographical Euclidean space,” says coauthor Professor Steven Strogatz, one of the pioneers of network science. “In reality, on top of the pure topology of who is connected to whom is the structure of actual distances. I think that the analysis of spatial networks, as in this paper, could be a really important area in the next few years.”

Source: “Redrawing the map of Great Britain from a network of human interactions,” by Carlo Ratti, Stanislav Sobolevsky, Francesco Calabrese, Clio Andris, Jonathan Reades, Mauro Martino, Rob Claxton, Steven H. Strogatz.PLoS ONE, 8 December 2010.

Funding: U.S. National Science Foundation, the AT&T Foundation, the National Defense Science and Engineering Fellowship Program, the MIT SMART program, GE, Audi Volkswagen, SNCF, ENEL and the members of the MIT Senseable City Lab Consortium.