Why American universities are questioning their historic entrance exam

Share:

THE ESSENTIALS

  • Created in 1926, the SAT, a standardized test, revolutionized access to American universities by standardizing entrance exams.
  • Its results remain very much linked to the social background of the students, which fuels criticism of its fairness.
  • Although it has become optional in most universities, the SAT remains an essential step for many high school students.

In June 1926, the SAT, a standardized American college admissions exam, was held for the first time. Some 8,000 high school students participated, hoping to gain admission to the most prestigious universities .

Since its creation a hundred years ago, the SAT has undergone numerous changes , both in its organizational methods and in the subjects and knowledge assessed.

A major turning point occurred around the year 2000, when some 280 institutions of higher education began allowing applicants to apply without providing their scores on the SAT or the ACT, another commonly used standardized test. Today, approximately 86% of American universities and institutions of higher education no longer require these scores to consider applications.

Whether the SAT accurately assesses students’ academic abilities remains a subject of debate . Some research suggests that the exam is a good indicator of their skills, knowledge, and chances of success in higher education .

Other research highlights fundamental flaws in the SAT and ACT, notably the fact that students from affluent families generally achieve better SAT scores . It’s worth noting that taking the exam is expensive, and wealthier families can afford private tutoring and specialized preparation. Their children also typically attend well-funded public or private schools.

As a professor of educational sciences , I believe it is essential to know the history of the SAT to understand the current debates surrounding this exam.

A new type of exam

The SAT was designed in the 1920s by the College Board, an organization founded in 1900 by the presidents of twelve major American universities to standardize admissions procedures for higher education. At the time, each university had its own entrance exam. These exams took the form of essays, written by applicants and then corrected and graded by professors.

In 1926, an identical SAT exam for all candidates was used for the first time . It consisted of 315 questions that students had to answer in 97 minutes, or about 18 seconds per question. However, they were not expected to answer all the questions.

The initial exam comprised nine sections , some of which resemble those students still take today, notably reading comprehension and arithmetic. Others, however, have disappeared, such as the artificial language test . This consisted of constructing coded sentences while adhering to a complex set of rules, for example: ” The plural is formed by adding -o .”

In 1928 and 1929, and again from 1936 to 1941, the SAT did not include any mathematics questions. Between 1930 and 1935, all mathematics questions were open-ended, not multiple-choice , unlike the practice generally used today. At the time, the SAT represented a true revolution: it broke with the essay-based exams, whose topics and questions were defined by professors at each university.

Multiple-choice and fill-in-the-blank questions could be graded quickly and objectively. High school students no longer needed to travel to a university campus to take an entrance exam. Thanks to the SAT, thousands of students could now take the same test close to home, without the inconvenience of traveling to university.

The results could be reviewed by several universities, rather than just one. The SAT thus intensified competition among candidates while simultaneously expanding access to higher education. However, not all universities, nor even all secondary school teachers, welcomed this innovation. Some feared, in particular, that the exam’s content would ultimately dictate high school curricula.

At that time, however, the SAT remained relatively little used: in the late 1930s and early 1940s , only about 10,000 students took it each year .

In 1947, the Educational Testing Service (ETS), a private, non-profit organization specializing in educational testing and research , was established to administer the SAT and design other tests. This organization had a vested interest in promoting the SAT to institutions of higher learning, which contributed to its widespread adoption.

The SAT is gradually becoming established

In the aftermath of World War II, American universities saw a surge in applications, largely due to the GI Bill . This government program provided veterans with financial assistance and benefits to pursue their studies .

Faced with this influx of applicants, universities have begun to tighten their admission criteria and rely more heavily on SAT scores to select students.

In 1960, the University of California system became the first major public university system to make the SAT mandatory . That same year, the ACT was created . Over the following decades, more and more institutions incorporated the SAT into their standard admissions criteria.

To limit the advantage that private tutoring could provide, the designers of the SAT also lengthened the exam and revised the questions .

In 1994, a new development marked the history of the SAT : for the first time, candidates were allowed to use a calculator during the exam.

Much more than just an exam

Taking the SAT or ACT is a major undertaking for students. Not only can their scores determine their university admission, but an improvement of just 50 to 100 points can also earn them thousands of dollars in scholarships.

The disparities in SAT scores between different racial groups are well documented and have been the subject of debate for decades.

Students of Asian descent achieve the best SAT scores on average, ahead of white students. Students from affluent families are 13 times more likely than those from modest backgrounds to score at least 1,300 points on the SAT, out of a maximum of 1,600.

Some research highlights a link between family income, exam results and academic success , the latter being measured by grades obtained, further studies and graduation.

Other research shows that high school grades are better predictors of college success than SAT scores.

Universities are questioning the SAT

Faced with questions about the usefulness of the SAT in student selection, some 280 universities and higher education institutions decided, around the year 2000, to make this exam optional in their admission procedures .

The start of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020 provided a large-scale experiment for admissions without mandatory standardized tests. The risk of virus transmission simply prevented students from taking the SAT . As a result, in 2020 and 2021, almost no university required SAT or ACT scores to consider applications.

Six years later, more than 2,000 universities and higher education institutions still do not require the SAT for admissions. However, this classification can be misleading , as obtaining certain scholarships may still be contingent on SAT scores.

In 2025, more than two million students, or about 47% of seniors , took the SAT . This is the highest number recorded since the start of the pandemic. That same year, 36% of seniors, or 1.38 million students, took the ACT.

A rite of passage for high school students

The SAT continues to evolve. In 2024, its duration was reduced from three hours to two hours and fifteen minutes . The exam is thus approaching its original length of 97 minutes , a century ago . Also in 2024, the SAT became entirely digital .

Today, this exam does not perfectly reflect the potential and skills of students, but it remains a rite of passage for most American high school students who plan to pursue their studies at university.

Author Bio: Beth Kania-Gosche is Professor of Education at Missouri University of Science and Technology

Tags: